The trouble with a custom that is meant to be frightening is that it works. In the
twentieth century, the cities with the densest Chinese populations started to count the
eyes, hands and houses it cost, and one after another they banned it.
Hong Kong comes through the account of the officer quoted above. In the 1960s
Wilson called a meeting of the fire brigade's chief officer and the medical department,
and all of them pressed for a ban; the manufacture of fireworks was already illegal in
the colony, and explosions at the factories across the water in Macao showed why. He
expected the government to refuse, and it did, for fear that, with riots already behind
it, a ban would give an excuse for more unrest. It was "several years" before it felt the
public would accept one, and then it sweetened the ban with an official fireworks display
over the harbor at Chinese New Year.
Singapore had a cracker war. In 1970, according to Culturepaedia, the
Singaporean encyclopedia of Chinese culture, the Ming Court Hotel bought over half a
million firecrackers to compete
with the new Hilton, whose string hung 26 stories high. In 1972 two unarmed policemen
were attacked with firecrackers, and that year the Dangerous Fireworks Act banned them
for good. When firecrackers were set off in Chinatown on New Year's Eve 2004, with
permits and safety precautions, 20,000 people came to hear the first ones in 32 years.
Beijing banned them in 1993, and many cities across China followed.
Twelve years later, in September 2005, Beijing gave up and lifted the ban, moving to
limits on where and when, though air pollution brought tighter rules again, including a
2017 plan to close everything inside the Fifth Ring Road. In December 2023 the
legislative affairs commission of the National People's Congress weighed in: national
law, it said, contains no blanket ban on fireworks that meet the standards, opinions on
total bans are divided and they are hard to enforce, so local rules should be revised in
the spirit of the higher law. The decision has gone back to each city, and every year
the argument starts again in the weeks before the
New Year.
Both sides of that argument are, in a way, making the same case the
Jingchu Suishiji made. The noise is meant to keep harm away from the household.
The question a modern city asks is only which harm is closer: the Shansao, or the
firecracker.